The Coltons of Mustang Valley

A Colton must solve a DNA mystery...

...and save his family from ruin.

One phone call suddenly upends Asher Colton’s life. He discovers his baby daughter might have been switched with single mom Willow Merrill’s. Worse, the day care owner vehemently hates his family. But for the babies’ sake, they work to uncover the truth about the births as threats to the Colton family—and Willow’s business—mount. But can the truth set free a love-scarred rancher and his harshest enemy?

DANICA WINTERS is a multiple-award-winning, bestselling author who writes books that grip readers with their ability to drive emotion through suspense and occasionally a touch of magic. When she’s not working, she can be found in the wilds of Montana, testing her patience while she tries to hone her skills at various crafts—quilting, pottery and painting are not her areas of expertise. She believes the cup is neither half-full nor half-empty, but it better be filled with wine. Visit her website at danicawinters.net

Also by Dana Nussio

Shielded by the Lawman

Her Dark Web Defender Strength

Under Fire

Falling for the Cop

Discover more at millsandboon.co.uk

In Colton’s Custody

Dana Nussio

www.millsandboon.co.uk

ISBN: 978-0-008-90504-0

IN COLTON’S CUSTODY

© 2020 Harlequin Books S.A.

Published in Great Britain 2020

by Mills & Boon, an imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers 1 London Bridge Street, London, SE1 9GF

All rights reserved including the right of reproduction in whole or in part in any form. This edition is published by arrangement with Harlequin Books S.A.

This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, locations and incidents are purely fictional and bear no relationship to any real life individuals, living or dead, or to any actual places, business establishments, locations, events or incidents. Any resemblance is entirely coincidental.

By payment of the required fees, you are granted the non-exclusive, non-transferable right and licence to download and install this e-book on your personal computer, tablet computer, smart phone or other electronic reading device only (each a “Licensed Device”) and to access, display and read the text of this e-book on-screen on your Licensed Device. Except to the extent any of these acts shall be permitted pursuant to any mandatory provision of applicable law but no further, no part of this e-book or its text or images may be reproduced, transmitted, distributed, translated, converted or adapted for use on another file format, communicated to the public, downloaded, decompiled, reverse engineered, or stored in or introduced into any information storage and retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the express written permission of publisher.

® and ™ are trademarks owned and used by the trademark owner and/or its licensee. Trademarks marked with ® are registered with the United Kingdom Patent Office and/or the Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market and in other countries.

www.millsandboon.co.uk

Note to Readers

This ebook contains the following accessibility features which, if supported by your device, can be accessed via your ereader/accessibility settings:

 Change of font size and line height

 Change of background and font colours

 Change of font

 Change justification

 Text to speech

To my hero of thirty years, Randy, who does all the

cooking, endures my deadline mania and makes it

possible for me to live my dream of writing stories all

day. I love you. To our daughters, Marissa, Caterina and

Alexa, who learned to fend for themselves during said

deadlines and have grown into strong women who are

courageously following their own dreams. And to

Isabelle Drake, Veronica to my Betty, the academic

who instructs me on how life imitates comic books and

the friend who reminds me to live the real thing

outside the pages.

Contents

Cover

Back Cover Text

About the Author

Booklist

Title Page

Copyright

Note to Readers

Dedication

Chapter 1

Chapter 2

Chapter 3

Chapter 4

Chapter 5

Chapter 6

Chapter 7

Chapter 8

Chapter 9

Chapter 10

Chapter 11

Chapter 12

Chapter 13

Chapter 14

Chapter 15

Chapter 16

Chapter 17

Chapter 18

Chapter 19

Chapter 20

Chapter 21

Chapter 22

Chapter 23

Chapter 24

Chapter 25

Chapter 26

Chapter 27

Chapter 28

About the Publisher

Chapter 1

Asher Colton latched the barn door and strode toward the corral, his favorite boots scraping the dusty earth in a comfortable rhythm. That the man he’d known for only two days matched him in both pace and in the number of scuffs on his boots made Asher grin. Those were small similarities, and they didn’t know anything for sure yet, so he schooled his features as he sneaked another glance at the guy next to him.

Unfortunately, Jace Smith caught him peeking, so Asher stared out over the open fields and banks of trees that made up Rattlesnake Ridge Ranch. With its rich red, Arizona soil stretching to the base of Mustang Valley Mountains and kissing the sky where the heights dipped, the Triple R was the only place Asher had ever been truly content.

Well, until recently.

Now the land he oversaw at least gave him an excuse to look away from the newcomer and prepare himself for whatever question he would pose next.

Instead of asking one, Jace cupped both hands over his headful of dark hair. “That sun is already a killer out here, even this early in the morning.”

The side of Asher’s mouth lifted. The guy might have seven more years of life experience than Asher’s thirty-three, but when it came to ranch education, their guest was as much a newborn as their spring calves were.

“What did you expect? It’s May in Mustang Valley. Highs are always in the mideighties this time of year. It’s not that different from anywhere in southeastern Arizona, is it?”

“Guess I spend too much time in the air-conditioning.”

“Ya think? Anyway, I told you to wear a hat.”

Asher adjusted his own and wiped sweat from his forehead as he’d already done a dozen times that morning. Unlike their guest, who’d been staying at the mansion the past few days, as ranch foreman, Asher had already been at work for hours.

“Yeah. Need to get me one,” Jace said, as he pulled out a pair of sunglasses and slipped them on.

“Would be a good idea.”

It was hard to believe anyone living in that part of the state wouldn’t already own a decent cowboy hat, especially someone who might be, well, a relative. He pointed farther up the panel fence with cedar posts and caps.

“Come on. I promised to show you the new additions.”

“Has it been a big season?”

“Great so far. We’re getting several hundred calves a day.”

“Are those good numbers?”

“Really good. Our operation runs over twenty thousand cows and another ten thousand heifers. Both Angus and Hereford. In case you don’t know, cows are females that have had at least one calf, and heifers are females that haven’t calved yet.”

“I know that. I’m not that much of a city slicker.”

“Good to know.” Asher doubted Jace was telling the truth but didn’t call him on his fib. It wasn’t the guy’s fault he’d been raised in the city. Or, possibly, by the wrong mother.

A few months earlier, Asher’s whole family had been rocked by the revelation that his oldest brother, Colton Oil CEO Ace, had been switched at birth. Since then, his dad had been shot, a crime in which Ace was a suspect, and was in a coma; the family had worked to track down the “real” Ace. Jace’s arrival at the ranch two days earlier had been a surprise, but if the information Jace had received was true, then they might have solved their mystery.

“This place is amazing. I’m lucky just to have seen it.” Jace looked up and down the fencerow. “If not for the earthquake last month, I might never have found the courage to find out for sure if I’m one of the babies someone switched at that hospital.”

“Tragedies definitely shake us up and spur us to action.” Asher was talking about his own family, but the other man was too caught up in his story to notice. “Oh. Pardon the pun. You know, spurs.”

Jace smiled over at him before returning to his story. “If I’d spoken to Luella anytime in the past decade, I could have asked her some questions about what that nurse had said, but I doubt she would have told me the truth. She never did about anything else.”

Asher purposely didn’t look at Jace then, giving him time to collect his composure. It was a kindness that men gave to each other.

“It’s too bad you had such a difficult relationship with your...well, the woman who raised you.”

That Jace always referred to Luella Smith by her first name was telling. Some mother she must have been.

Asher had kept it to himself that his two brothers were still tracking Luella, the woman who had apparently switched her healthy son for a sickly baby, Ace, but Jace’s connection to her gave his story credibility.

“Bet that keeps you busy.”

Caught lost in his thoughts, Asher blinked. Jace gestured toward the field. He was clearly trying to change the subject, a ploy Asher should have been familiar with since he used it whenever anyone brought up his ex-girlfriend, Nora.

“We’re busy, all right. No sleep for ranchers or ranch hands during calving season. Poor Harper. Half of her nighttime diaper changes have come from the housekeepers and the kitchen staff lately.”

Twice as many in the daytime, too, now that his most recent nanny had hightailed it out of town. His shoulders drooped over the slim pickings he would face in yet another candidate search. How was he supposed to prove that as a single dad, he could be a better parent than his father ever had been, when he couldn’t keep consistent childcare for his six-month-old daughter?

“Cute kid, by the way.”

“Thanks.” Asher couldn’t help grinning at that. It was hard not to like a guy who complimented his baby.

“Strange, isn’t it?”

“What?” Asher slid a glance his way. “Not sleeping or changing diapers. I get a lot of practice at both.”

“I bet you do, but that’s not what I meant. It’s just this whole situation. I still can’t get used to it. I keep looking for any physical resemblance between us.”

“Find any?”

“With you? Not so much.”

“That would be less likely. Either way.” Asher rushed to add the second part.

Why did he keep getting ahead of himself? They had no proof yet. He owed it to his family to remain skeptical until they did. Ace deserved at least that much.

Anyway, Jace was right. Asher looked no more like the guy than he did his adopted brother, Rafe. Jace bore no resemblance to Asher’s full siblings, blond twins Marlowe and Callum. On the other hand, with all that dark hair and those blue eyes, Jace fit right in with Asher’s half brother, Grayson, and half sister, Ainsley, the other two children of Payne’s first marriage. Everyone at the mansion had noticed.

“Guess we’ll know for sure soon enough.”

Asher startled as the other man seemed to have read his thoughts. “S’pose so.”

He gave the dirt an extra kick and ground his molars. They might as well have been talking about the weather rather than the life-altering reality that Jace might be the real Ace.

Just thinking it made him feel disloyal to the man he knew as Ace. If only they could turn the clock back four months, to the time before that mysterious email had drop-kicked his family’s world and the structure of Colton Oil. Before they’d learned about the baby switch. He longed for those days of blissful ignorance.

“How do you think Ace is doing?” Jace asked.

Not as well as you. Somehow, Asher managed not to say that out loud, though Jace’s questions from the past two days were starting to annoy him. “As well as can be expected for a guy whose life has been flipped on its head.”

“I get that.”

Asher shrugged. Jace clearly could relate to receiving news that had changed his life, but it was probably easier for someone to discover that a silver spoon might be slipped in his mouth than to have one yanked out, along with a few teeth.

“It’s just that Ace is the only one of your siblings I haven’t met yet,” Jace continued. “I totally understand why the others are keeping their distance until after the DNA test. I appreciate that they at least dropped by and introduced themselves.”

“Six of seven isn’t too bad for just two days.”

His siblings were curious. No one could blame them for that when they might have been meeting Payne Colton’s real firstborn with his late first wife, Tessa, for the first time.

“But Ace’s situation is a little different,” Jace continued.

“He’s been busy, too.”

If lying low back at his loft condo in the city’s industrial zone—or at the Dales Inn in town—counted for busy anyway. In Ace’s defense, he had to stay put while the media trucks lingered at the hospital and just outside the ranch’s main gate.

“Is he still considered a suspect in your dad’s attempted murder?”

Asher bit back the temptation to tell Jace to mind his own damn business. Depending on the results of the test they’d scheduled, Colton family matters just might be his business.

“He’s been questioned and told not to leave town. Now you know everything I do.”

“What about Payne? Any updates on him?”

“Nothing beyond what Ainsley told you two nights ago.”

“That’s what I figured.”

If Jace noticed the edge to Asher’s voice, he didn’t show it. Anyway, there was no more to say. His dad was still in a coma, and there was no guarantee when, or even if, he would ever awaken.

“He’ll wake up.”

Asher stiffened, the other man rightly guessing his thoughts again.

“Hope so.”

“When did you say Ainsley would pick me up for the test?”

“About twelve thirty. Appointment’s at one.” Not soon enough for Asher. At least then it would be her turn to play Twenty Questions with Jace.

“I knew that. I’m just nervous, I guess.”

Asher shifted his feet. The Coltons weren’t the only ones whose lives were in flux. Still, that didn’t make him want to talk about it. Or think about it. Good thing they’d finally reached the near side of the calving pasture, where several cows were nibbling grass and nursing their young.

“These are some of our newest arrivals.”

He leaned forward to rest his forearms on the six-inch-wide fence cap, and the other man followed his example.

“Wow, the calves are amazing.”

That was something they could agree on. If nothing else on the Triple R made sense to Asher lately, this land and the cattle were things he understood.

“See that calf closest to the fence?” He pointed to an animal with distinctive markings on its head and legs. It was pulling voraciously on its mother’s teat. “He just showed up last night. Thought he was never going to get up on his legs.”

“Looks like he made it.”

“Yeah.” His lips lifted. After a rocky start, the little guy was doing just fine. Asher had secretly been calling the calf “Lucky Boy,” but he couldn’t let it get out that the foreman was nicknaming new arrivals.

“What was wrong with him?” Jace asked.

“A healthy calf usually stands up and nurses in the first two hours. Those from difficult births, like him, sometimes take longer. It’s critical that calves nurse within the first four hours to benefit from the antibodies in colostrum. If they don’t, we’re forced to tube feed them.”

Jace made a sad face as he watched the animal several seconds longer.

“Poor little guy. What did you end up doing?”

“Just as we started to intervene to give him his best chance for survival, he popped up on his feet and went to his mom for breakfast.”

“Sounds like a lucky calf to be born on the Triple R. Are you calling him Lucky?”

“We don’t give them nicknames.”

“That’s not a rule, is it?”

Asher shifted his head so Jace wouldn’t see his grin. He still didn’t want to get ahead of himself, but he had a good feeling about Jace. It would be nice to have at least one sibling who cared about animals as much as he did. His cell buzzed in his back pocket, interrupting his thoughts. He pulled out the phone and checked the number to make sure it wasn’t Neda, one of the housekeepers, calling about Harper. Usually, he let business calls go to voice mail and answered them when he returned to his office at the back of the barn, but he froze at the words on the caller ID. Mustang Valley General Hospital? Had his dad’s condition changed? Or worse? Maybe Payne Colton wasn’t the kind of dad people wrote greeting cards about, but that didn’t mean Asher wanted him to...

“Sorry. I should take this.”

He stepped away and turned his back before tapping the button to answer the call. “Rattlesnake Ridge Ranch. May I help you?”

“Have I reached Asher Colton?” a female voice asked.

“This is Asher.” He squeezed the phone tighter and pressed it against his ear.

“My name is Anne Sewall. I am the administrator at Mustang Valley General Hospital.”

“Has something happened with my father?” he blurted before he could stop himself.

His heart thudding, he clamped his free arm to his side and waited for the worst news he could imagine.

“Oh. No.” The woman made a strange sound into the phone. “You’ll have to call the nurse’s station on the floor for specifics on your father’s condition. I’m sorry for causing you distress.”

“Then why are you calling?”

It was a testament to his superior restraint that he didn’t include the hell in his question. What had she thought he would assume? It wasn’t a secret in town that his dad was a patient at Mustang Valley General.

“There’s another, unrelated matter that we need to discuss. I was hoping that you could bring your infant daughter to my office today and—”

“What are you talking about? And what do you want with Harper? Was there something the pediatrician missed in her six-month checkup?”

“No.” Her nervous chuckle filtered through the connection. “It’s not that. Again, I apologize, Mr. Colton. I realize that this is unusual. But if you’ll just meet me in my office, I’ll explain the whole situation.”

“I would rather that you explain it right now.” His mother had always called him stubborn, and he was proving her right, but he couldn’t help it. This woman had already frightened him twice, and he wasn’t about to let her go for a hat trick.

“That would be highly irregular.” She cleared her throat again. “This is a delicate matter. We don’t customarily divulge this type of information over the phone.”

“Well, I would say that it’s not usual to phone a community member out of the blue and, in the space of two minutes, give him concerns about both his father and his child.” He didn’t care if he was the one jumping to those conclusions. She should have explained herself better.

“Fine.” She sighed. “Obviously, this information would be more appropriate if given in person.”

“Noted. So?”

“I’m sorry to inform you that there’s a possibility that your daughter, Harper Grace Colton, and another infant, also born on November 2, might have been accidentally switched in Mustang Valley General’s nursery.”

“Again?”

He didn’t care if his question came out as a yelp. Was this a joke? In what realm of possibility could there be two Colton babies—albeit forty years apart—who’d been switched at birth?

“How could you let this happen?”

“Now, we don’t know anything for certain, Mr. Colton. That is why we’re asking you and the other party to bring your infants in immediately for DNA tests.”

She prattled on about how sorry the hospital board was for this possible mix-up, but he wasn’t listening. All he could think about was his sweet little Harper, with her crop of light brown hair, those dimples like his and eyes as brown as Nora’s. How could there be a chance that she wasn’t his? Or Nora’s, if a mother who abandoned her baby could even count as one.

Harper was his. She looked just like him. Everyone said so. He shook his head to dismiss the unfathomable possibility that they weren’t even related.

“What kind of bumbling hospital are you guys running?”

“We deeply regret this possible mistake. Thankfully, we’ll be able to clear up the questions with a DNA test. It won’t hurt the infants. Just a cheek swab.”

She spoke about it as if it was only an inconvenience, like an online retailer mixing up two customers’ packages. As if the results of those tests wouldn’t have the power to destroy not one but two families.

“I’ll be there as soon as I can.”

With that, he clicked off the call. He didn’t care if his tone was rude.

“Everything all right?”

Asher’s shoulder blades squeezed together. He’d forgotten that he wasn’t alone. He glanced at Jace. Concern etched in lines between the man’s brows. Jace’s shoulders were back, his arms pressed to his sides, as if he was preparing himself for bad news. The kind that could devastate a guy who thought he’d just found his father.

“It’s not about Dad,” Asher said automatically, not even bothering to include my. It was the decent thing not to worry the guy unnecessarily about Payne, like the hospital administrator had done to him.

Jace’s shoulders dropped forward. “Thought I’d never get the chance to meet him. If we find out he and Tessa really are my parents, then I already missed the chance to know one of them.”

Asher nodded, staring at the ground. He couldn’t imagine what it would be like for a guy to track down his possible biological parents, only to learn that one of them had passed away years before. He couldn’t think about that just then, either. One crisis at a time.

“Look, there’s something I need to take care of. Can you hang around the ranch until my sister picks you up? Our cook, Dulcie, will make you whatever you like for lunch if you stop by the main house kitchen.”